Mix + Match Pack of 6

(5 reviews) Write a Review
Gift wrapping:
Options available
Mix + Match Pack of 6

Handpick your favorite assortment of slow-cultured, small-batch butters. Comes in a package of 6 5oz. rounds.  Ready to stock up? Try a 12 pack

Choose from Unsalted, Sea Salt, Roasted Garlic, Basil & Parsley, Cinnamon Cardamom & Ginger, Smoked Sea Salt, and our limited-release seasonal flavors. 

What is Cultured Butter Anyway?

The vast majority of butter sold in America is sweet cream butter. That means that, after the cream is pasteurized, it is immediately churned.

That also means that it has very little taste. So, to give it flavor, many butter manufacturers add “natural flavoring,” or “lactic acid.”

Butter churned from sweet cream lacks the flavors that can only come from a long-ripening process where a special mixture of bacteria is added to the cream and held at precisely the right temperature, for precisely the right amount of time.

This good bacteria is one of the things that makes our butter taste so good.

If you’ve ever eaten butter from small creameries in France, Italy, or Denmark, then you’ve had cultured butter. And if your great grandma made her own butter on the farm, then you’ve eaten cultured butter too.

Let’s reclaim the way butter should be, shall we?

See more FAQ here

5 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5

    Posted by Judy on Mar 22nd 2021

    My 2nd time to purchase, not my last by any means. The Garlic, basil, parsley butter makes the best mashed potatoes we've ever eaten. The noney butter I'd eat on anything. It makes delicious toast and muffins but also sweet potatoes (although the cinnamon, cardemon, ginger comes in a close second). You just can't beat it. I wish they were sold in grocery stores here in Florida.

  • 5

    Posted by Judy on Nov 10th 2020

    I took a leap of faith on a couple of these flavors but to my delight they are all SCRUMPTIOUS! I highly recommend these butters.

  • 5
    6-pack Banner Butter

    Posted by Jeffrey Bell on Jun 10th 2020

    Tried this butter after being referred by my son. We grill allot. This is a great tasting butter.It can be used while cooking or as an add on after cooking.

  • 5
    The Best Butter with the Best Options

    Posted by Ce on Jun 8th 2020

    While traveling I found this butter in North Carolina. I purchased the Smoked Sea Salt and put it on everything from popcorn to eggs. ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS! When I returned to DC area I couldnt find it so got online and ordered this pack and the 12 pack. The BBQ is even better than the Smoked Sea Salt which I didnt think possible. On Broccoli and Baked Potatos unebeliveable. The package came in two days still cold.! Thank you!!!! Trying Garlic Chive and Lemon and Garlic Basil tonight with Chicken. I called on a Sunday and they returned my call in 10 minutes!! Best customer service and best product!

  • 5
    Butter so good you can eat it straight!!!

    Posted by Pam on Jul 4th 2018

    And honestly I do eat it straight. Yeah its THAT good. The Sea Salt is my personal favorite, my son likes the Roasted Garlic, Basil & Parsley. This butter has an amazing flavor (sea salt) almost like the butter on popcorn from when i grew up in the 70's. It is the only butter I buy now and if I can't get it from my local store I order online in bulk and freeze it. ;) Oh and really, I actually will slice a piece off, slice a piece of cream cheese to top it with and eat it just like that. SOOOO Delicious