Mix + Match Pack of 12

(2 reviews) Write a Review
Gift wrapping:
Options available
Mix + Match Pack of 12

Handpick your favorite assortment of slow-cultured, small-batch butters. Comes in a package of 12 5oz. rounds.  Not ready to stock up? Try a 6 pack Mix & Match 6.

Choose from Unsalted, Sea Salt, Roasted Garlic, Basil & Parsley, Cinnamon Cardamom & Ginger, Smoked Sea Salt, and our limited-release seasonal flavors. 

How is Banner Butter Different?

We’re different in several ways.

First, the cream. It’s fresh. Like, really fresh. That’s because it comes from Georgia cows, local to us.

Second, it’s grass-fed. Our cows graze in green pastures and are not treated with hormones.

Third, the butterfat. We make butter that is has a higher proportion of butterfat than other butters.

Fourth, the method. Before churning, we let the cream ripen for many, many hours. This ripening process allows good bacteria to form. It is this good bacteria that gives butter its complex buttery undertones.

Next, after the cream ripens, we slowly churn it in small batches.

This process results in a better tasting product because we are able to make small adjustments throughout churning, depending on the season, the consistency, and the taste of the cream.

Finally, our butter is hand-cut and lovingly packaged. That’s why no two packages look exactly the same. In the end, it takes us 20 times longer to make our butter than industrial scale butters.

So if you want something special, give us a try!

 A note about shipping: Currently we only ship butter on Mondays and Tuesdays. Orders placed after midnight on Monday are typically shipped the following week. View all shipping policies here

2 Reviews Hide Reviews Show Reviews

  • 5
    1st Time Purchase

    Posted by Craig McDonald on Nov 19th 2021

    I'd seen these used on MeatChurch and found a local spot that sells them but too much of a drive. I decided to order the 12 pack mix & match - they shipped quickly and arrived almost still frozen - immediately put them into the deep freezer. I've tried the Sea Salt, Smoked SeaSalt and the BBQ and they are ALL AWSOME! What an outstanding way to finish off my meats!
    Customer service is excellent, I had a couple of the wrong butters shipped and the let me keep the wrong ones and quickly sent out the missing ones. If you haven't tried them - this is the way to go... My understanding is the butters will remain good in the freezer for 12 months, so buys 12 is no problem. Enjoy, I sure am as are all my guests!

  • 5
    Two time customer

    Posted by Janetta Mihalacki on May 17th 2021

    I bought a batch of this butter after discovering the product on Instagram. The sweet and savory tastes add so much to my cooking prep. I returned and ordered double for Mother's Day. I want to gift friends and family with several batches.